After a while, I finally managed to recreate this problem on one of my accounts. It's actually a major problem but I
should be able to fix it.
It should be updating on a duplicate entry but it's not, thus causing some weird issues. When the fix is up I'm probably also going to have to have you guys clean out the table (by deleting it and readding it), so everyone will have their plays reset properly.
Sooooo I'll get back to you on that!!